THERMAL SCIENCE

International Scientific Journal

Thermal Science - Online First

Dick-Fung Szeto

,

Ching-Mei Wu

,

Wan-Ki Chow

,

Chi-Honn Cheng

,

Cheuk-Lun Chow

online first only

Discussion of thermal activation on heat collection plate of sprinkler heads

ABSTRACT
Heat collection plates (HCP) are installed above sprinkler heads in some tall halls in the Asia-Oceania region to give faster thermal actuation. In this study, experiments were thus conducted in a fire chamber to determine thermal activation times of sprinkler heads with and without HCP. Three HCPs with different diameters were selected and tested with pendent fast response liquid-in-bulb sprinkler heads. A total of 48 sprinklers heads were studied under different conditions of height and pool fire size. HCP was found to reduce sprinkler activation time in a fire chamber test by up to 61%. Thermal activation time of sprinkler heads was also investigated by the common plunge test in a wind tunnel. Results indicate that activation was delayed by 5%, 18% and 221% on average by the three HCPs. An HCP of pie plate shape with small diameter would alter the physical scenario of heating up the heat sensing element of sprinkler heads assumed in the plunge test. Therefore, the effect of HCP cannot be appropriately assessed in a wind tunnel.
KEYWORDS
sprinkler head, heat collection plate, thermal response
PAPER SUBMITTED: 2023-04-02
PAPER REVISED: 2023-06-06
PAPER ACCEPTED: 2023-06-09
PUBLISHED ONLINE: 2023-09-02
DOI REFERENCE: https://doi.org/10.2298/TSCI230402176S
REFERENCES
  1. Ivanov, M.L., Chow, W.K., Fire Safety in Modern Indoor and Built Environment, Indoor Built Environ, 32 (2023) 1, pp. 3-8
  2. NFPA 13 Standard for the Installation of Sprinkler Systems, 2019 edition. National Fire Protection Association, USA
  3. BS EN 12845:2015+A1:2019 Fixed Firefighting Systems - Automatic Sprinkler Systems - Design, Installation and Maintenance. British Standards Institution, UK, 2019
  4. Fire Services Department, Codes of Practice for Minimum Fire Service Installations and Equipment and Inspection, Testing and Maintenance of Installations and Equipment. Hong Kong, 2022
  5. Chow, W.K., Performance of Sprinkler in Atria, J Fire Sci, 14 (1996) 6, pp. 466-488
  6. Yang, K.H., Yeh, T.C., Design Analysis and Experimental Investigation of the Smoke Management System Performances of an HSR Station, Int J Architectural Science, 6 (2005) 3, pp. 106-113
  7. Chow, W.K., et al., Numerical Studies on Atrium Smoke Movement and Control with Validation by Field Tests, Build Environ, 44 (2009) 6, pp. 1150-1155
  8. Chow, W.K., On the Evaporation of Sprinkler Water Spray, Fire Technol, 25 (1989), pp. 364-373
  9. Arnott, M., et al., Application of a Judgement Method to Regulatory Impact Assessments for Sprinkler Protection to English High-Rise Residential Buildings, Fire Mater 45 (2021) 6, pp. 811-822
  10. Lin, S.L., et al., Effect of Heat Collector Plate on Thermal Sensitivity of Sprinkler Heads in Large Terminal Halls, J Build Eng, 25 (2019) 100787
  11. NRC Information Notice 2002-24: Potential Problems with Heat Collectors on Fire Protection Sprinklers.
  12. Tsai KC, et al., Validating the Function of Absorber Plates for Auto-Sprinkler System Activation, Proceedings of 10th Asia-Oceania Symposium on Fire Science and Technology 2015, Springer Science+Business Media Singapore, 2017, pp. 851-857
  13. Chow, W.K., Cheng, A.C.K., Preliminary Studies on Thermal Sensitivity of Fusable Links with a Wind Tunnel, Int J Engineering Performance-Based Fire Codes, 9 (2007) 1), pp. 1-6
  14. The Standard for Installation of Fire Safety Equipments based on Use and Occupancy. Taiwanese Regulation, Taipei, Taiwan, 2011
  15. Heskestad, G., Smith, H.F., Plunge Test for Determination of Sprinkler Sensitivity. FMRC 3A1E2.RR, Factory Mutual Research Corporation, Norwood, MA, December 1980
  16. Theobald, C.R., Thermal Response of Sprinklers Part I. FRS Heated Wind Tunnel, Fire Saf J, 12 (1987) 1, pp. 51-63
  17. Melinek, S.J., Thermal Response of Sprinklers - A Theoretical Approach, Fire Saf J, 3 (1988) 2/3, pp. 169-180
  18. Chow, W.K., Ho, P.L., Thermal Response of Sprinkler Head. Build Serv Eng Res Technol, 11 (1990) 2, pp. 37-47
  19. US 5497834A. Sprinkler Head with Plate for Absorbing and Indicating Shocks Thereto. United States Patent Number 5497834, 12 March 1996
  20. Chow, W.K., Wu, H.H., Thermal Sensitivity of Fusible Links for Hotel Projects, J Applied Fire Science, 14 (2009-2010) 2, pp. 123-132
  21. Liu, J.S., et al., Analysis of the Effectiveness of Heat-Collection Plate, Procedia Eng, 135 (2016), pp. 160-169
  22. Liu, H., et al., Critical Assessment on Operating Water Droplet Sizes for Fire Sprinkler and Water Mist Systems, J Build Eng, 28 (2020) 100999
  23. National Fire Protection Association, NFPA 13 Standard for the Installation of Sprinkler Systems, 2019 Edition, USA.
  24. British Standards Institution, BS EN 12845:2015+A1:2019 Fixed Firefighting Systems - Automatic Sprinkler Systems - Design, Installation and Maintenance, UK, 2019
  25. Novozhilov, V., Application of Heat-Balance Integral Method to Conjugate Thermal Explosion, Thermal Science, 13(2009), pp. 73-80
  26. Jia, Z.W., et al. Propagation Law of Flame in a Pipeline Produced in Gas Explosion Numerical Analysis and Experimental Verification, Therm Sci, 25 (2021), pp. 2199-2204
  27. Hung, H.Y., et al., Observation on a Fire Whirl in a Vertical Shaft Using High-Speed Camera and Associated Correlation Derived, Therm Sci, 25 (2021) 2, pp. 1001-1012
  28. Zatao-Samedi, O. et al., Effect of Ratio between Incoming Cool Air and Outgoing Hot Gases on Behaviour of Compartment Fire, Therm Sci 25 (2021) 1A, pp. 221-228
  29. Xi, Y.H., et al., Numerical Simulation on Temperature in Wood Crib Fires, Therm Sci, 25 (2021) 4A, pp. 2621-2636
  30. Ho, H-H., et al., Numerical Studies on an Accidental Flash Fire at a Water Fun Park by FLACS software, Therm Sci, 26 (2022) 2C, pp. 1721-1732
  31. Wang, Y., et al., Wind Action on Whirling Flame Characteristics, Therm Sci, Appeared online first, 10 September 2022
  32. ISO 6182-1:2021, Fire protection — Automatic sprinkler systems — Part 1: Requirements and test methods for sprinklers. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland
  33. ISO 6182-7:2020, Fire protection — Automatic sprinkler systems — Part 7: Requirements and test methods for early suppression fast response (ESFR) sprinklers. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland
  34. ISO 6182-10:2014, Fire protection — Automatic sprinkler systems — Part 10: Requirements and test methods for domestic sprinklers. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland
  35. ISO 6182-13:2017, Fire protection — Automatic sprinkler systems — Part 13: Requirements and test methods for extended-coverage sprinklers. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland
  36. Legislative Council Panel on Manpower Safety in the Use of Tower Cranes on Construction Sites, LC Paper No. CB(2)2480/07-08(01), Labour and Welfare Bureau, Labour Department, July 2008
  37. Hong Kong Housing Authority, Safety & Health Circular No. 10/2009 Alert on Safe Handling of Tower-Crane Lifting Operations, 9 July 2009
  38. The Standard, One Hospitalized as San Po Kong Fire Burns for More Than Four Hours, 28 January 2023 www.thestandard.com.hk/breaking-news/section/4/199666/
  39. Chow, W.K., On the Fire Safety Requirements for Existing Old Buildings, Int J Engineering Performance-Based Fire Codes, 9 (2007) 1, pp. 31-37 www.academia.edu/79723821/
  40. Lo, C., et al., Collapsed Tower Crane that Killed 3 Workers in Hong Kong Suspected To Have Had ‘Obvious Faults' at its Base, South China Morning Post, 7 September 2022 www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/society/article/3191621/tower-crane-collapses-and-knocks-container-8-workers-hong
  41. Kong, H., Lo, C., Mirror Concert Accident: Fallen Screen at Hong Kong Show Weighed Twice Value Reported to Authorities, South China Morning Post, 25 August 2022 www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/law-and-crime/article/3190162/weight-screen-fell-mirror-concert-and-injured-two
  42. The Standard, Bosses Could Be Fined HK$10m, Jailed Two Years for Safety Breaches as Latest Bill Passes, 19 April 2023 www.thestandard.com.hk/breaking-news/section/4/202780/
  43. South China Morning Post, Beijing District Official Apologises After Hospital Fire Kills 29 People, Injures Dozens, 19 April 2023 www.scmp.com/news/china/politics/article/3217559/death-toll-beijing-hospital-fire-rises-29-dozens-injured
  44. South China Morning Post, Safety Checks at Skyscraper After Hong Kong Firefighters Battle Blaze for 9 Hours in Major Shopping District Tsim Sha Tsui, 3 March 2023 www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/law-and-crime/article/3212152/two-taken-hospital-after-major-fire-hits-skyscraper-under-construction-hong-kongs-tsim-sha-tsui
PDF VERSION [DOWNLOAD]
Discussion of thermal activation on heat collection plate of sprinkler heads