International Scientific Journal


This work presents a procedure for direct numerical minimization of entropy production in a diabatic tray column with heat exchanged on the trays as control variables, as opposed to previously used procedures with temperature on the trays as control variables. The procedure, which had previously been demonstrated on a binary mixture, was in this work applied to a multicomponent mixture, with minor modifications. The procedure comprised the complex optimization method and the Ishii-Otto method for solving the equations of a column model based on the iterative Newton-Raphson technique with partial linearization of the equations. The desired separation of the components was realized by the addition of a penalty function to the goal function, i.e. entropy production in the column. The required thermodynamic characteristics were calculated by the Soave equation of state. As an illustration, an industrial debutanizer with five components was used whose data, obtained by simulation, were compared with the optimization results of a diabatic column with the same desired separation and number of trays. After the diabatic column optimization procedure, the value of 91.91 J/Ks was obtained as the best result for entropy production. According to the best solution, entropy production in the diabatic column was 23.2% lower than in the adiabatic column. The heat to be removed from the column increased by 24.7%, while the heat to be added to the column increased by 28.8%.
PAPER REVISED: 2019-06-08
PAPER ACCEPTED: 2019-06-17
CITATION EXPORT: view in browser or download as text file
THERMAL SCIENCE YEAR 2020, VOLUME 24, ISSUE Issue 3, PAGES [2256 - 2266]
  1. Kaiser, V., Gourlia, J.P., The ideal column concept: Applying exergy to distillation, Chemical Engineering, 92 (1985), 17, pp. 45-53
  2. Tondeur, D., Kvaalen, E., Equipartition of Entropy Production. An Optimality Criterion for Transfer and Separation Processes, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 26 (1987), 1, pp. 50-56
  3. Kjelstrup Ratkje, S. et al., Analysis of Entropy Production Rates for Design of Distillation Columns, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 34 (1995), 9, pp. 3001-3007
  4. Sauar, E., Kjelstrup Ratkje, S., Lien, K.M., Equipartition of Forces: A New Principle for Process Design and Optimization, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 35, (1996), 11, pp. 4147-4153
  5. Salamon, P., Nulton, J.D., The geometry of separation processes: A horse-carrot theorem for steady flow systems, Europhysics Letters, 42 (1998), 5, pp. 571-576
  6. Andresen, B., Salamon, P., Optimal distillation using thermodynamic geometry, in: Thermodynamics of Energy Conservation and Transport (Eds. A. DeVos, S. Sieniutycz), Springer Verlag, 2000, pp. 319-331
  7. Alcántara-Avila, J.R., Sotowa, K.-I., Horikawa, T., Entropy production and economic analysis in diabatic distillation columns with heat exchangers in series, Energy, 93 (2015), pp. 1719-1730
  8. Schaller, M. et al., Numerically optimized performance of diabatic distillation columns, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 25 (2001), 11-12, pp. 1537-1548
  9. de Koeijer G.M. et al., Comparison of Entropy Production Rate Minimization Methods for Binary Diabatic Distillation, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 41 (2002), 23, pp. 5826-5834
  10. Schaller, M. et al., The Influence of Heat Transfer Irreversibilities on the Optimal Performance of Diabatic Distillation Columns, Journal of Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics, 27 (2002), 3, pp. 257-269
  11. Sauar, E., Siragusa, G., Andresen, B., Equal Thermodynamic Distance and Equipartition of Forces Principles Applied to Binary Distillation, The Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 105 (2001), 11, pp. 2312-2320
  12. de Koeijer, G., Røsjorde, A., Kjelstrup, S., Distribution of heat exchange in optimum diabatic distillation columns, Energy, 29 (2004), 12-15, pp. 2425-2440
  13. Andersen, T.R. et al., Energy Efficient Distillation by Optimal Distribution of Heating and Cooling Requirements, Proceedings, (Ed. S. Pierucci), ESCAPE-10, Pisa, Italy, 2000, pp. 709-715
  14. Jimenez, E.S. et al., Optimization of a Diabatic Distillation Column with Sequential Heat Exchangers, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 43 (2004), 23, pp. 7566-7571
  15. Røsjorde, A., Kjelstrup, S., The second law optimal state of a diabatic binary tray distillation column, Chemical Engineering Science, 60 (2005), 5, pp. 1199-1210
  16. Johannessen, E., Røsjorde, A., Equipartition of entropy production as an approximation to the state of minimum entropy production in diabatic distillation, Energy, 32 (2007), 4, pp. 467-473
  17. Shu, L., Chen, L., Sun, F., Performance optimization of a diabatic distillation-column by allocating a sequential heat-exchanger inventory, Applied Energy, 84 (2007), 9, pp. 893-903
  18. Spasojević, M., Đ., Janković, M.R., Đaković, D.D., A New Approach to Entropy Production Minimization in Diabatic Distillation Column with Trays, Thermal Science, 14 (2010), 2, pp. 317-328
  19. Sauar, E. et al., Diabatic Column Optimization Compared to Isoforce Columns, Energy Conversion and Management, 38 (1997), 15-17, pp. 1777-1783
  20. Andresen, B., Salamon, P., Thermodynamic Geometry Determines Optimal Temperature Profile in Distillation Column, in: Methods and Applications of Inversion, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 92, 2000, pp. 15-30
  21. Mendoza, D.F., Riascos, C.A., Design and optimization of diabatic single and double feed distillation columns with sequential heat exchangers, 2nd International Conference on Engineering Optimization, September 6-9 (2010), Lisbon, Portugal
  22. Kjelstrup, S., Bedeaux, D., Johannessen, E., Gross, J., Non-Euilibrium Thermodynamics for Engineers, World Scientific, Singapore, 2010
  23. Burgos-Madrigal, P., Mendoza, D.F., López de Haro, M., On Entropy Generation and the Effect of Heat and Mass Transfer Coupling in a Distillation Process, Journal of Non-equilibrium Thermodynamics, 43 (2018), 1, pp. 57-74
  24. Ishii, Y., Otto, F.D., A general algorithm for multistage multicomponent separation calculations, Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 51 (1973), 5, pp. 601-606
  25. Soave, G., Equilibrium constants from a modified Redlich-Kwong equation of state, Chemical Engineering Science, 27 (1972), 6, pp. 1197-1203
  26. Reid, R.C., Prausnitz, J.M., Poling, B.E., The Properties of Gases and Liquids, 4th ed., McGraw Hill, New York, 1987
  27. Box, J.M., A New Method of Constrained Optimization and a Comparison with other Methods, Computer Journal, 8 (1965), 1, pp. 42-52
  28. Soares Pinto, F., Zemp, R., Jobson, M., Smith, R., Thermodynamic optimization of distillation columns, Chemical Engineering Science, 66 (2011), pp. 2920-2934
  29. Salehi, G.R., Salehi, A., Ghorbani, B., Amidpour, M., Maleki, M., Kimiaghalam, F., A Pareto Front Approach to Bi-objective of Distillation Column Operation Using Genetic Algorithm, Energy Science and Technology, 3 (2012), 2, pp. 63-73
  30. Özeçelik, Y., Mert, S.O., Exergoeconomic Distillation Sequencing by Multi-objective Optimization through a Hybrid Genetic Algorithm, Chemical and Biochemical Engineering Quarterly, 30 (2016), 3, pp. 305-315

© 2022 Society of Thermal Engineers of Serbia. Published by the Vinča Institute of Nuclear Sciences, National Institute of the Republic of Serbia, Belgrade, Serbia. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 International licence