International Scientific Journal

Thermal Science - Online First

online first only

Thermal performance analysis and optimization design of dry type air core reactor with the double rain cover

In this paper, a fluid-thermal coupled finite element model is established according to the design parameters of dry type air core reactor. The detailed temperature distribution can be achieved, the maximum error coefficient of temperature rise is only 6% compared with the test results of prototype, and the accuracy of finite element calculate method is verified. Taking the equal height and heat flux design parameters of reactor as research object, the natural convection cooling performance of reactor with and without the rain cover is investigated. It can be found that the temperature rise of reactor is significantly increased when adding the rain cover, and the reasons are given by analyzing the fluid velocity distribution of air dcuts between the encapsulation coils. In order to reduce the temperature rise of the reactor with the rain cover, the optimization method based on the orthogonal experiment design and finite element method is proposed. The six factors of the double rain cover are given, which mainly affect the temperature rise of reactor, and the five levels are selected, the influence curve and contribution rate of each factor on the temperature rise of reactor are analyzed. The results show that the contribution ratio of the parameter H1, L1 and L2, are obviously higher than the parameter H2, L3 and θ, so the more attention should be paid in the design of double rain cover. Meanwhile, the optimal structural parameters of rain cover are given based on the influence curves, and the temperature rise is only 43.25ºC. The results show that the optimization method can reduce the temperature rise of reactor significantly. In addition, the temperature distribution of inner encapsulations coils of reactor are basically the same, the current carrying capacity of coils can be fully utilized, which provides an important guidance for the optimization design of reactor.
PAPER REVISED: 2021-01-18
PAPER ACCEPTED: 2021-01-20
  1. Liu, Z.G., et al., The Optimum Design of Dry-type Air-Core Reactor, High Voltage Engineering, 29(2003), 2, pp. 17-20 (into Chinese)
  2. Papp, K., et al., High voltage dry-type air-core shunt reactors, E & I Elektrotechnik und Informations technik, 131(2014), 8, pp. 349-354
  3. Liu, H. Y., Wei, B., Operation and Maintenance of Dry Air Core Reactor, High Voltage Apparatus, 40(2004), 3, pp. 239-241 (into Chinese)
  4. Zhang, H., Cai, Y. L., Fault Analysis on Dry-type Air core Reactor in 500 kV Substation, Power Capacitor and Reactive Power Compensation, 37(2016), 1, pp. 46-50 (into Chinese)
  5. Wang, P., et al., Distribution of electric field and structure optimisation on the surface of a ±1100 kV smoothing reactor, IET Science, Measurement & Technology, 13(2019), 3, pp. 441-446
  6. Wu, S., Wu, D., Yan, S., A study of design and calculation method for dry-type reactor with air core, Transformer, 34(1997), 3, pp. 18-22 (into Chinese)
  7. Ye, Z., Temperature Rise Test of Dry-Type Air-Core Reactor and Calculation of its Winding Temperature Rise, Transformer, 36(1999), 9, pp. 6-12 (into Chinese)
  8. Wu, C. J., Investigation on the temperature distribution in a reactor and design of measure system by optical fiber sensor system, Master's thesis, Northwestern Polytechnical University, Xi'an, China, 2005
  9. Xiong, H., Chen, W. G., Du, L., et al., Study on Prediction of Top-oil Temperature for Power Transformer Based on T-S Model, Chinese Journal of Electrical Engineering, 27(2007), 10, pp. 15-19 (into Chinese)
  10. Liu, Z. G., G, Y. S., W, J.H., et al., Design and analysis of new type air-core reactor based on coupled fluid-thermal field calculation, Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, 18(2003), 6, pp. 59-63 (in Chinese)
  11. Yuan, F., Yuan, Z., Wang, Y., Thermal optimization for nature convection cooling performance of air core reactor with the rain cover. IEEJ Transactions on Electrical and Electronic Engineering, 13(2018), 7, pp. 995-1001
  12. Jiang, Z. P., Wen, X.S., Wang, Y., et al., Test and coupling calculation of temperature field for UHV Dry⁃type air⁃core smoothing reactor, Proceedings of the CSEE, 35(2015), 20, pp. 5344⁃5350 (in Chinese)
  13. Smolka Jacek, Nowak Andrzej J., Shape optimization of coils and cooling ducts in dry-type transformers using computational fluid dynamics and genetic algorithm, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 47(2011), 6, pp. 1726-1731
  14. Z Mohammed Sami Mohammed, Revna Acar Vural., NSGA-II+FEM based loss optimization of three phase transformer, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 66(2019), 9, pp. 7417-7425
  15. Bin, X., Gil-Gyun Jeong, Chang-Seop Koh., Co-kriging assisted PSO algorithm and its application to optimal transposition design of power transformer windings for the reduction of circulating current loss, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 52(2016), 3, pp. 1-4
  16. Yuan F., Yuan Z., Chen L., et al., Thermal and Electromagnetic Combined Optimization Design of Dry Type Air Core Reactor, Energies, 10(2017), 12, pp. 1989
  17. WU, C. Z., Zhou, J. B., Zhao, J. M., et al., Influence of rain and wind on Air-core reactor, Power Capacitor and reactive Power Compensation, 35(2014), 2, pp. 40-42+49 (in Chinese)
  18. Yuan, F. T., Yuan, Z., Wang, Y., et al., Thermal optimization for nature convection cooling performance of air core reactor with the rain cover, IEEJ Transactions on Electrical and Electronic Engineering, 7(2018), 13, pp. 995-1001.
  19. Wang, Q. W., Chen, Q. Y., Zeng, M., A CFD-Taguchi combined method for numerical investigation of natural convection cooling performance of air-core reactor with noise reducing cover, Numerical Heat Transfer Part A Applications, 55(2009), 12 pp. 1116-1130
  20. Deng, Q., Li, Z. B., Yin, X. G., et al., Steady thermal field simulation of forced air-cooled column-type air-core reactor, High Voltage Engineering, 39(2013), 4, pp. 839-844
  21. David, P., et al., Comparison between BEM and classical FEM for a 3D low-frequency eddy-current analysis, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 46(2010), 8, pp. 2919-2922
  22. Kurt, P., et al., Eddy current losses in large air coils with layered stranded conductors, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 44(2008), 6, pp. 1318-1321
  23. Yan, X.K., et al., Research on calculating eddy-current losses in power transformer tank walls using finite-element method combined with analytical method, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 52(2016), 3, pp. 1-4
  24. Wang, H., et al., Numerical Calculation and Experimental Verification for Leakage Magnetic Field and Temperature Rise of Transformer Core Tie-Plate, IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity, 29(2019), 2, pp. 1-5
  25. Tsili, M., et al., Power transformer thermal analysis by using an advanced coupled 3D heat transfer and fluid flow FEM model, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 53(2012), pp. 188-201
  26. Santisteban, A., et al., Thermal Modelling of a Power Transformer Disc Type Winding Immersed in Mineral and Ester-Based Oils Using Network Models and CFD, IEEE Access, 7(2019), pp. 174651-174661
  27. Yuan, Z., et al., Thermal Analysis of Air core Power Reactors, ISRN Mechanical Engineering., (2013) pp. 1-6
  28. Yuan, F.K., et al., Optimization Designof Oil-Immersed Air Core Coupling Reactor for a 160 kV Mechanical Direct Current CircuitBreaker, Energies, 12(2019), 6.
  29. Yuan, F.K., et al., Optimization Designof a High-Coupling Split Reactor in a Parallel-Type Circuit Breaker, IEEE Access, (2019), 7, pp. 33473-33480.